This decorative Ontario vernacular home at 233 Second Street has a long history.

The subdivision plan for this area of the west end of the Village of Stouffville was surveyed on Dec. 10, 1881 for William Somerville. The corner of Charles St. and Second was a double Lot being lots 52 and 53 which was about 1-½ acres.

The first owner was David Williams who purchased it to build this fine house. He paid $175 for both lots in 1887 and took out a mortgage of $140.

Mr. Williams also took a mortgage of $500 which would indicate that he was building a residence.

Mr. Williams sold to Mr. Daniel Grove in Dec. 1889 for the price of $750 again for both parcels of land. Mr. Grove lived there for over 12 years. He was a railroad Section man.

It is interesting to note the fire insurance map of 1910 shows this building as a frame 2-story with a 1-½ story addition on the rear and single story storage on the north end of the addition. The 1924 fire insurance map shows no changes.

The executors of Mr. Grove sold the land to Mr. Allan B. Closson in 1923 for $2200.

Mr. Closson had been a farmer on Lot 4 Concession 9 (Ninth Line) just north of the village. He came to town with his wife Lottie and their son Donald R. Closson.

Back in 1916, Mr. Closson was ill with peritonitis before his life-saving surgery was done by Dr. Robertson who was the chief surgeon of Sick Kids Hospital at that time. This is another connection of Stouffville to Sick Kids Hospital in Toronto.

Mr. Closson held the position of Secretary for the United Farmers Organization. As a market gardener he grew cauliflower and cabbage and expanded his crops to include onions.  The oral history tells of an onion barn on the next property on Second St. which was later converted to a private home in 1947. It was described as being 26 ½ by 8 ½ and the lot was included for sale.

Following a lengthy illness, Mr. Closson passed away in the Brierbush Hospital on Oct. 6, 1966. He was 77 years of age.

3 thoughts on “233 Second Street

  • This is my Closson family. Some of what Fred siad I know but the rest was new to me. My grandfather Donald Robert Closson moved to Toronto in 1941. So what I know about Stouffville is limited to family stories and what I have found on my own. One thing I can tell you is that the house next door at 239 2nd street was also owned and built by Allen Bruce Closson. He likily owned 233 first and lived in it until 239 was built before moving in. After selling his farm Allen bought many properties in town and made money renting them out to people. He became a landlored. 233 ended up being the house his parents to live in their old age. Robert (Bob) Bruce Closson and Sara Tripp.

    • We live at 239 second street now. Allan Closson came back with his son to visit a few years ago. He told us he had built this house with his dad. The date he gave us was 1934.

  • We purchased it from the Middletons and lived lived there from February 1994 to October 2016. We updated the shed behind to a 2 car garage and did some interior decorating. We loved the area and our neighbours. We were sorry to move away but wanted to downgrade to a smaller house. When we bought, Stouffville was known as the “County Close to the City” and basically had 1 traffic light in town and 1 at both ends of the Town. It certainly was no longer that when we moved to the outskirts of Lakefield in 2016, which is indeed country close to the City of Peterborough lol. We have very fond memories of our home at 233 Second Street and our time in Stouffville.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This